Short & Sweet: Curing Autoimmune Disease & To D or not to D?
Short answer: Don't D. Longer but still comparatively short answer: see below
![The Life and Death of the Library of Alexandria ‹ Literary Hub The Life and Death of the Library of Alexandria ‹ Literary Hub](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F6ea09017-3489-4555-b2d8-f35b4f0b2fb1_2800x1720.jpeg)
Executive Summary
Why does your body attack itself in autoimmune disease? Because it's "confused"?
No. I'll tell you why, but first let's discuss what causes it in the first place: stress (bear with me).
Chronic stress is destructive.
Perhaps the biggest most pervasive stressor that's been with you from day one, and every day since, is one most people never even consider: artificial light at night.
Light triggers cortisol which is the stress hormone. Cortisol inhibits immune system function (and raises insulin, BP, body fat, etc). Obviously we need some cortisol, but like very good thing there is a Goldilocks sweet spot. Too much or too little are harmful, we need it just right. Too much light means too much cortisol means not enough immunity means invasion of pathogens means chronic inflammatory diseases, especially autoimmune diseases.
So your body attacks its own tissues to root out the pathogens, not because it's "confused".
But autoimmune disease is usually treated with immunosuppressants. This is like holding back your armed forces from destroying an invader.
Surely your functional/alternative doc knows what's up? Vitamin D to the rescue! Immune booster extraordinaire!
Except supplemental vitamin D in autoimmune disease is immunosuppressive. Again the symptoms get better, because inflammation is your immune system activated, but it's the same fundamental approach as a corticosteroid.
You have to get to the bottom of things to get better, which means diagnosing the rock bottom problem that led to this.
Usually stress and toxic insults lead to weakening of the body and specific tissues, then beneficial microbes may flourish to help the body bind toxins, or metabolize nutrients, and pathogens may also take advantage of the situation. The immune system is activated but either not strong enough, or held in check by successive rounds of suppressive “medications” that lessen symptoms.
Once you understand autoimmune disease the solution is obvious. Fix the underlying causative factors, strengthen the body by correcting the internal and external environment, and assist the immune system in expelling toxins and microbial overgrowth.
The (Compressed) Details, Especially re: Vit D
Research by Marshall and others shows that Autoimmune disease is actually due to overgrowth of our own microbiome as well as pathogenic bacteria which can invade our own tissues and even take up residence inside our own cells. So our immune system only attacks our own tissues and cells because they are harboring an infection. Suppressing immune function as in the mainstream paradigm will improve symptoms initially but data shows the disease comes back stronger 5, 10 or even 20 years later.
The alternative medicine approach of giving vitamin D is based on finding low levels of 25-D, which is the precursor to the hormonally active form 1,25-D, and it’s presumed that their levels are closely correlated. 1,25-D is not usually directly checked because it is much more expensive. It is assumed that low 25-D levels in inflammatory diseases mean there is a deficiency of vitamin D in the body contributing to the problem.
What Marshall and colleagues have shown repeatedly over the last 15+ years is that 1,25-D is actually more often than not very high in autoimmune and other chronic inflammatory diseases, even while 25-D is low.
One key to understanding what is going on is to realize that vitamin D is a misnomer. Vitamins are necessary micronutrients. “Vitamin” D is actually a hormone used by the body to send signals between cells. Hormone levels are tightly controlled by environmental inputs like light-dark cycles, stress, food, activity, emotions, and physiological inputs like other hormonal levels, the microbiome, and pathogens. Hormones have extremely complex and intricate feedback loops and vitamin D is no exception.
Another key is that Marshall and colleagues have shown with modeling studies that 25-D is as hormonally active as its metabolite 1,25-D, it just has an opposite effect - it blocks the activation of the vitamin D receptor (VDR), whereas 1,25-D activates it. So the level of VDR activation depends on the balance between the levels of both versions of vitamin D in the body. This is the opposite of the consensus view which considers 25-D as physiologically inert, not even meriting mention in one of the 1000 page vitamin D textbooks I consulted.
The final key to understanding how vitamin D levels relate to autoimmune disease is understanding the activating the VDR leads to the immune system being mobilized to fight off invasive and pathogenic bacteria. So the body raises 1,25-D levels and lowers 25-D levels in order to activate the VDR. The 1,25-D levels often rise very high and can’t go higher due to feedback loops - the VDR can only be so turned on. Turning the dial any further is useless.
In this situation when supplemental vitamin D is given it is converted into 25-D, but cannot be further converted into 1,25-D since the body doesn’t want any more and is suppressing that conversion step. However by driving 25-D levels higher you are deactivating the VDR and lowering immunity.
Now it seems this approach works in the short to medium term because an immune attack on tissues to root out bacteria is itself what leads to the inflammatory symptoms of autoimmune disease. Patients feel like they get better, the same way they get better when taking steroids or other immunosuppressants from their rheumatologist. The difference in that case being patients know they are just masking symptoms, whereas in the case of vitamin D they are misled to believe they are fixing the root cause issue.
However in both cases, underneath the surface, the bacteria continue to multiply out of control since the immune system is being held back.
Diagnose, Then Treat
Let the body do what it’s trying to do, and help it out. At the same time make sure you dig until you hit rock bottom, i.e. you have to ask: why did this happen in the first place?
Usually stress and toxic insults lead to weakening of the body and specific tissues, then beneficial microbes may flourish to help the body bind toxins, or metabolize nutrients, and pathogens may also take advantage of the situation. The immune system is activated but either not strong enough, or held in check by successive rounds of suppressive “medications” that lessen symptoms.
Perhaps the biggest stressor is one most people never even consider: artificial light at night (ALAN).
Light triggers cortisol which is the stress hormone. Cortisol inhibits immune system function (and raises insulin, BP, body fat, etc).
Obviously we need some cortisol, but like very good thing there is a Goldilocks sweet spot. Too much or too little are harmful, we need it just right.
Too much light means too much cortisol means not enough immunity means invasion of pathogens means autoimmune disease (and a whole host of other modern disease states developing, often waiting in the wings to spring on you as you get older).
Anyone who is any good at fixing anything in the real world will tell you that the only way to go about it is to first diagnose the problem.
This is not the way mainstream physicians go about it, despite tossing around the word “diagnose” all the time. They will be the first to tell you 99% of the time that they don’t know what caused your illness no matter how common it is or how many decades or centuries it’s been studied or how many expensive tests they order. Yet people still allow them to “practice” their craft on their sick bodies.
Once you understand autoimmune disease the solution is obvious. Fix the underlying causative factors, strengthen the body by correcting the internal and external environment, and assist the immune system in expelling toxins and microbial overgrowth.
For much more detail on all of this and a lot of things that didn’t fit here see the full post where I discuss corrupted Hegelian dialectics, orthogonal thinking, VDR disruptors, the Marshall protocol, super-organisms, supplementing in general, eating fish, and some of the many wonders of sunlight.
"Once you understand autoimmune disease the solution is obvious. Fix the underlying causative factors, strengthen the body by correcting the internal and external environment, and assist the immune system in expelling toxins and microbial overgrowth. "
HOW?
Consider this question in relation to someone with FMS and long covid and two excised stage 1 cancers, both that were not effectively removed.
I have no access to an integrative practitioner. I have a typically ignorant GP, but a helpful one, and so find myself battling to lead him in what to do. I am trying to direct him towards finding the cause of my dramatic health collapse in the last 2 years, but he cannot understand the concept of finding an underlying cause. Trouble is, I don't know what to do either - I am not a doctor. So can you tell me so I can tell him?
1. What tests he should run to identify an issue with Vitamin D (or whatever is underneath that - Vitamin A maybe?)
2. To convince himself of what? (All his actions must be justified to a central authority so he must be able to defend expensive tests and protect himself in case of litigation.)
3. What results from those tests trigger what responses - presuming there may be different treatments based on differing test results - simplified of course to the most common issues and treatments.
(Perhaps you could design this as you would design some kind of scientific trial, one designed to demonstrate your theories, and put them to the test. I would be happy to pass the instructions onto my doctor and volunteer as an informal, unofficial trial subject to see whether you are right or wrong. )
I have had enough of this incessant pain, stiffness and weakness that has rendered me unable to live life even to the most minimal degree. I want a resolution.
Completely agree with you regarding stress.
As someone with a clinical diagnosis of HIV+ (Sep 2013) to have this show up then occurred on the heels of extreme stress. Reigniting financial earnings as a white male mid-life middle management (retail/showroom visual presentation) burned by sacrificing home and financial security by an altruistic streak (chronic self-sacrifice on steroids to transform the plight of LGBT experience c2000) produced a transformation just not the one anticipated.
Spinning my wheels to restore personal security merely set the downward groove to go deeper. From Retail Visual Presentation Manager homeowner with car in the metropolis to penniless, homeless, jobless on government unemployment of $625 / month. Live on that for 2.5yr qualifies for stress on steroids.
Culminating with HIV+ symptoms in January 2013 - medical incompetence delivering an HIV+ diagnosis nine months later.
The root - ever mysterious, powerful and tenacious - lodged in childhood emotional abuse, discovered through EFT Therapy (Emotional Focused Therapy) 2018. Solidly explained in the ACE Study of the 1990's.
Early childhood stress, sublimated, watered and tended to daily, grow deep deep tenacious roots with or without light.